Garage Door Repair vs. New Installation: What to Consider

repair vs new installation icon

Should you repair your existing garage door or scrap it for an entirely new installation? That’s probably the question we get asked the most over the years repairing and installing new garage doors in Roseville, Ca. And 9 times out of 10, the homeowner asking the question already knows the answer. If you need a new door, you’re probably aware it’s an issue, even if you’re not quite ready in terms of your household budget. Here are some factors to consider when weighing this decision.

How Old Is Your Garage Door?

If your garage door hasn’t been replaced in the last couple decades, you probably should consider installing a new door. Older garage doors don’t have the safety features of modern garage doors — and this can be dangerous, especially if you’ve got kids or pets. For instance, any door installed before 1993 might not even have photoeyes, so there’s nothing to stop the door if a kid or pet suddenly runs underneath. That’s one reason why garage doors cause thousands of injuries and hundreds of deaths every year.

Is Your Door Constantly Having Issues?

Any garage door more than a few years old will have issues from time to time. Springs need to be replaced. The door will need balanced occasionally. Sometimes a door gets off track or a track is bent. And doors will need require regular maintenance such as oiling and bolt tightening in order to function properly.

But if you’re constantly having problems, that’s a sign you might need to install a new garage door. You’re already spending money on repairs. We know how much of a hassle it can be — especially considering how much most people depend on their garage doors. And there’s the safety issue. Aging doors can be dangerous.

How Does Your Door Look?

You might not be able to judge a book by its cover, but people will judge your home based on how your garage door looks. Curb appeal is the single most important factor when it comes to property value. That’s why a new garage door has one of the highest ROIs when it comes to home improvement, virtually dollar for dollar. Your home will be worth more with a new door — something to consider if you plan on putting the house up for market.

Being Too Cheap Can Be a Mistake

A garage door is a sound investment — but not if you’re cheap about it. Since a door can be so important to property value, home security, and convenience, it’s worth doing right. Plan a budget for your new garage door. Talk to your bank about a home improvement loan. Consider using this year’s tax refund on a new door. This is a purchase most homeowners make only once or twice in their lives. It’s worth doing right.

Energy Savings

A new door can also substantially save your energy bill, even in Roseville, California. If your garage door is attached to the house, it can affect the cost of your air conditioning during the hot summers. This is why you should consider an insulated door even when the weather is warm. It will cost less to cool your home — and that can mean big savings over the long term.


Planning to sell the house? You still might consider new installation over repair. The truth is that installing a new garage door can substantially increase the value of your home. In fact, it has one of the highest returns on investments for all home improvements — 98%, virtually dollar for dollar. The reason for this is curb appeal, the single biggest factor in determining price. Make the most of Roseville, California’s booming real estate market with a new garage door that will deliver real value on your investment.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top